Ticce Posted 6 years ago
Grammar
What have you said?
Is it true that when someone says something obscene or insulting it is OK to use the present perfect:
- What have you (just) said? (We heard what the person said but we are indignant.)
but if we didn't hear what was said we should use the past simple:
- What did you say?
Top answer
Ticce Is it true that when someone says something obscene or insulting it is OK to use the present perfect:- What have you (just) said? ) This is not a usual thing to say in this situation. " in both of your cases.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
0
TicceIs it true that when someone says something obscene or insulting it is OK to use the present perfect:-
What have you (just) said? (We heard what the person said but we are indignant.)
This is not a usual thing to say in this situation. Normally we say "What did you (just) say?" in both of your cases. The tone of voice and general context will usua
0