0
Hanuman_2000 Posted 22 years ago
Grammar

Vowel

Sir,

IT was written in a English grammar book


There is no word in English that has not a vowel in it.


but the words like "by" ,"my" do not have vowel.

Please explain it.

Thanks.
  

Top answer

Vowels are sounds, not letters. Every word has a vowel sound. 'Y' is used to represent that vowel sound in some words, like 'by', 'my'', 'rhythm', etc.

Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

8 Answers
0
Vowels are sounds, not letters. Every word has a vowel sound. 'Y' is used to represent that vowel sound in some words, like 'by', 'my'', 'rhythm', etc.



PS: This-- 'There is no word in English that has not a vowel in it'-- hardly came from an English grammar book written by a native speaker.
0
I agree with Mister Micawber about the semantics. The word [sound] is implied:

"There is no word in English that has not a vowel [sound] in it."

Moreover, the letter is called a semi-vowel, so in actuality it's a vowel, albeit "semi-". The word "Rhythm" is an example: is pronounced as . In the case of "by" and "my", is pronounced as [ai], a diphthong, which is also a vowel
0
How ironic. If anything, Nietzsche's writings teach us to think for ourselves, and yet we do him injustice by using his thoughts to express ourselves.
0
This is interesting:

In the Danish and Swedish and also in French, the "Y" indeed IS a vowel!!
(his might be true for some other languages as well.)

Greetings
-Pemmican
0
If the intent was to express myself, I would not have attributed the quote to anyone. I would have claimed it as my own. By quoting it, I only intend to offer it to others for consideration.

P.S. I wouldn't get too bent out of shape about doing injustice to a dead man; there are too many living men to whom injustice is done; we would do well to pay more attention to them.
0
Having reread the sentence, just now, I see its tone is not what I intended to express at the time. My deepest apologies, Jim. My intention was to mark the irony, not to place a spot light on those of us, myself included, who quote the man. Sorry. It wasn't meant to be a personal attack, but it does in fact read that way. Agh.
0
I understand. All is well. Emotion: smile