Anonymous Posted 16 years agoGrammar
Uncontracted Negatives
(a) Isn't Zelda leaving for Paris?
(b) Is Zelda not leaving for Paris?
A linguist explains that (a) is the question for "Zelda is not leaving
for Paris."
She then adds that (b) is "word negation, rather than
sentence negation, and the scope of negation is different." She also
says that "not" emphasizes one word but does not tell the reader
which word. (I guess she assumes that her readers are smart enough
to guess. Sadly, I am not.)
Would someone please explain to me in simple English that I
can understand what she was saying? In other words, what is
the difference in meaning between (a) and (b)?
Thank you VERY much.