Anonymous Posted 16 years ago
Grammar
"or indeed" apposition: with or without commas?
"Needless to say, confrontations with strong-willed horses, or indeed any horse, are usually a battle lost." (http://bnc.bl.uk/BNCbib/AD.html#ADF - for lack of a better example)
When using this expression - e.g. "thinking of him (or indeed myself) I can't help but be surprised" - I often find myself wondering whether "indeed" should be enclosed in commas.
I've seen it used both with and without commas, and was wonering whether there's a correct version.
Any pointers would be appreciated!
PS: Not sure whether this phrase actually qualifies as apposition - corrections welcome.
When using this expression - e.g. "thinking of him (or indeed myself) I can't help but be surprised" - I often find myself wondering whether "indeed" should be enclosed in commas.
I've seen it used both with and without commas, and was wonering whether there's a correct version.
Any pointers would be appreciated!
PS: Not sure whether this phrase actually qualifies as apposition - corrections welcome.
Top answer
The commas are not needed if the 'or' is present and the phrase is short and you do not wish the reader to pause and think.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
0
The commas are not needed if the 'or' is present and the phrase is short and you do not wish the reader to pause and think.
00