Curiouscat Posted 16 years ago
Grammar
Is this Past Perfect?
Hi All,
i was watching Britain's Got Talent the other day, after Janey Cutler's performance, host 1 goes out on stage to usher her back, and on their way out, Janey gives a bow, host 1 bows to the crowd as well.
Host 2 waiting backstage sees this and says:
"What's he bowing for? He hadn't done anything?"
Is hadn't done considered past perfect? I mean, it's usually used prior to another past action right? or is this a grammatical exception of some sort?
Thanks!
i was watching Britain's Got Talent the other day, after Janey Cutler's performance, host 1 goes out on stage to usher her back, and on their way out, Janey gives a bow, host 1 bows to the crowd as well.
Host 2 waiting backstage sees this and says:
"What's he bowing for? He hadn't done anything?"
Is hadn't done considered past perfect? I mean, it's usually used prior to another past action right? or is this a grammatical exception of some sort?
Thanks!
Top answer
That is past perfect, and it is a result of the fact that much of spoken grammar is internalized. Host 2 is thinking 'He hadn't done anything when he bowed'.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
0
That is past perfect, and it is a result of the fact that much of spoken grammar is internalized. Host 2 is thinking 'He hadn't done anything when he bowed'.
00
Hmmm. That's a good point. So it's possible then to imply something happened in the past when using the past perfect.
0