Gerund

Question

Sir, 1. She spent her days cooking food. here She =subject spent=verb indirect object=her days cooking=? 2. She spent her days to cook food. Why "to cook" is not possible here. Thanks.

PoorRichard · Accepted Answer

Sentence 1 is correct: the phrase is 'to spend time' + gerund.

'Cooking' here is the gerund.

Hanuman_2000 · Answer

Hello,

He spent her days making money.

he=sub
spent =verb
her days=Ind. obj.
making money=?

Thanks.

CalifJim · Answer

He spent his days making money.

he = subject
spent = verb
his days = Direct object (What did he spend? - his days)
making money = adverbial phrase of manner (How did he spend his days? - making money)

Hanuman_2000 · Answer

Sir,

He spent her days making money. ok.

He spent her days to make money.

why "to make " is not possible.

Thanks.

Jandi · Answer

- He spent her days to make money.

IMHO, this means;
In order to make money, he spent her days.

Therefor, it doesn't make sense.

Am I right, teachers?

PoorRichard · Answer

Hanuman, the construction here is:

'to spend [unit of time] + gerund + object of gerund', e.g.

'to spend [the weekend] + drinking + beer'
'to spend [an hour] + watching + television'

Some verbs are followed only by the gerund, some by the infinitive, and some by either the gerund or the infinitive. Unfortunately, you have to learn the correct constructions one by one, as there isn't a reliable rule.

This construction takes the gerund, and so 'to make' isn't idiomatic.

Jandi, I understand what you mean, when you replace 'to' with 'in order to'. As you have discovered, the sentence then doesn't make sense. This is because the phrase 'he spent his days' requires a 3rd element: 'the way in which he spent them'.

Gerund

Top answer

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬